Oct 01 2008

Which Do You Love: Writing or Being a Writer?

Published by Steve Osborne at 2:31 pm under Life and Writing

The question came early in my career, and it came from another writer. “Steve,” he said, “Do you love writing? Or do you just love being a writer?”

I had never thought about it like that. But there it was – a reality check question I couldn’t avoid.
I’d wanted to be a writer ever since I could remember. So yes, I loved the fact that I was a professional, full-time writer. I was proud of it. For me – a romantic at heart – it was the most romantic thing I could do.

But did I love writing in and of itself? After a few seconds of reflection, I realized that was another “Yes.” I loved it when ideas and words came to me. I loved it when suddenly, at the keyboard, I broke into laughter at something that spilled out of me. I loved those occasions when the words that splashed onto the computer screen brought tears to my eyes. I loved it when it seemed that something else – something beneath or beyond my own consciousness – took over. I loved being completely surprised by what came out. And I loved it when other people read those things and were affected by them.

When I was a junior in high school, I wrote some freelance humor columns and feature articles for The Salt Lake Tribune. I remember walking around our neighborhood when I came to difficult parts as I wrote my articles and feeling the thrill of having the right ideas, words and phrases come to me.

I remember waking up each morning one of my articles was published, running out to get the newspaper, and realizing that tens of thousands of people (maybe more) would read my article that day and see my photo next to it. I was not an exhibitionist. In fact, I was the guy who liked to sit back and observe rather than be noticed. But knowing that people all over the region – people I knew and didn’t know – were reading my writing that day gave me an incredible rush. It was my own quiet form of exhibitionism, and I absolutely loved it. I also loved going to school that day and having other students tell me they saw, read and liked the article. What a high!

So yes, I loved writing and I loved being a writer. I still do.

What about you? Do you write because you love writing in and of itself, or because you love the idea of being a writer? This is an important question, because if you don’t intrinsically love the act and process of writing just for itself, you will never have the passion to continue writing. Writing can be more difficult than breaking rocks, and you have to love doing it or you won’t last. The love of being it won’t keep you going for very long.

Something similar happens with physical workouts. I have been working out at gyms regularly since I was 19 years old. I like being fit, but I love the physical and mental feelings I get from a good workout. I have seen countless people come into the gym and have a good go at it for a period of time, then quit. I have seen others make workouts an ongoing part of their lives. The difference? The people who quit love being fit, but don’t like to work out. Those who make workouts a lifelong habit love being fit, too. But more than that, they actually love working out – they become addicted to the feelings they get while they’re doing it.

Same with writing. You’ve got to love it while you’re doing it or you won’t stay with it. I’m not saying the process of writing has to always be enjoyable. Don’t confuse “enjoyment” with “love.” You can love people and still want to scream at them. You can love them and still be hurt by them. But you love them still. That’s what love is.

So ask yourself whether you love writing or merely love the idea of being a writer. And be honest with your answer. If you don’t love the act and process of writing, give it up and find something you can love. Life is too short for self-deception.

Share and Enjoy:
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

9 Responses to “Which Do You Love: Writing or Being a Writer?”

  1. Kimberleeon 01 Oct 2008 at 3:20 pm

    That is a beautiful post! I must say “yes” and “yes!” I love writing, the highs and the lows of it, the days when the words won’t come and the days when they flow like magic. I love being a writer, sharing my words with anyone who will read them.

    It’s a blessing to be a writer!

    This post just about brought tears to my eyes, Steve. Bravo!

  2. Gary Fletcheron 02 Oct 2008 at 2:31 am

    For me it’s writing I love. I try to avoid the “being” thing as far as possible and focus on things I like “doing”. “Being” can just be limiting. Maybe you can’t “be” a writer for some reason, but if you love writing you can always find ways to do it, whatever your job title.

  3. Magnoliaon 02 Oct 2008 at 4:29 am

    I absolutely love writing. I hate deadlines and demands on my writing, however,and one would think at 51, I would have managed to overcome the dread that seems to settle into every nook and cranny of my brain when they are present.

    I feel like a junky with the thrill and deep satisfaction I get when the inspiration is there and I know I’ve put something worthwhile on paper. There is nothing like it.

    I’ve never thought of myself as a writer…….at least not outloud. It is a moniker that I don’t feel good enough to claim for my own right now. But, I keep trying. In the meantime, I will simply enjoy the process.

  4. Marcuson 03 Oct 2008 at 4:35 am

    for it’s writing I love. I am not a professional write and I keep a Moleskine journal which I split hafl way into a diary and half way in my journal. I only write for myself and to be “writer” you would need to have the intention to go public which I don’t have.
    I just love the feeling when I start a new page, see it filling and get my head empty at the same time.
    I agree with Gary, it’s the “doing” not the “being” that is important to me.

  5. Luv YAon 03 Oct 2008 at 8:50 am

    [...] knew I’d love this post as soon as I saw the title. Which Do You Love: Writing or Being a Writer.  I honestly think there are times you fall in both category, either or neither. As your life [...]

  6. [...] Which do You Love: Writing or Being a Writer? [...]

  7. Why Writing Wins « RPL Writeson 06 Oct 2008 at 6:36 pm

    [...] in Writing Thoughts at 1:36 am by rplcomm Last week, Steve Osborne at The Writer’s Bag posted an article about the writing process that I have not been able to get off my mind.  The title of the post asks, “Which do you love:  [...]

  8. Princess April Annon 22 Oct 2008 at 8:14 am

    I know it’s hard to become a writer some writers get four hours of sleep they drink two cups of coffee or lots of tea. My Parents told me it isn’t easy for me to be a writer they don’t want me to be a writer at all they want me to work in an office which is better.
    I want to write love stories and also children’s books. Maybe I should start thinking about writing school at home or in public.

  9. Steve Osborneon 22 Oct 2008 at 8:58 am

    April Ann, the whole world told me not to become a writer. I have been a full-time writer now for about 25 years, have a happy marriage, raised three wonderful children, live in a beautiful home…. I’m not bragging — I just want you to know that with hard work and dedication (and a bit of aptitude for it) you can make your way in life as a writer and be happy you did. Follow your bliss!

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply

Comments for this post will be closed on 19 July 2011.